Table of Contents
If you're planning a patio cover, carport, or sunroom, you'll need to choose between standard aluminum pan roofing and insulated panels. This guide cuts through the technical details to help you make a practical decision.
The Quick Answer
Choose standard aluminum if: Basic weather protection is all you need and budget is tight.
Choose insulated panels if: You want to actually use and enjoy the covered space comfortably.
Now let's explore why.
What Standard Aluminum Does Well
Standard aluminum pan roofing is the budget option, and it handles basics adequately:
Good for:
- Keeping rain off
- Providing shade
- Protecting vehicles or equipment
- Covering areas used briefly or rarely
- Projects with limited budgets
Common applications:
- Carports
- Equipment storage covers
- Basic patio shade
- Utility structures
If you just need to keep rain and direct sun off something, standard aluminum works.
What Standard Aluminum Doesn't Do
Standard aluminum has significant limitations:
Comfort issues:
- Gets very hot underneath (10-20°F above shade temperature)
- Radiates heat downward like a broiler
- Uncomfortable for extended use
Noise issues:
- Loud during rain (drumming sound)
- Can be disruptive to conversation
Structural limitations:
- Cannot walk on for maintenance
- Cannot support ceiling fans
- Limited span between posts (8-12')
- Flexes and oil-cans in wind
If comfort, quiet, or functionality matter, standard aluminum falls short.
What Insulated Panels Provide
Insulated panels address all the limitations of standard aluminum:
Comfort:
- 10-15°F cooler underneath
- Blocks radiant heat
- Actually comfortable in Florida summers
Quiet:
- Foam core absorbs sound
- Rain is a gentle patter, not a drumroll
- Normal conversation during storms
Functionality:
- Walk-on strength for maintenance
- Support ceiling fans and recessed lights
- Span up to 20' between posts
- Rigid—no flexing
- Finished ceiling appearance
Insulated panels create space you'll actually want to use.
Real-World Decision Scenarios
Scenario 1: Carport for your car
You want to keep rain and sun off your vehicle. You won't be spending time there.
→ Standard aluminum works. The car doesn't care if it's hot under the roof.
Scenario 2: Patio for outdoor dining
You want to eat meals, entertain friends, and relax outdoors.
→ Insulated panels recommended. Comfort makes the difference between using the space and avoiding it.
Scenario 3: Sunroom addition
You're enclosing a space for year-round use with climate control.
→ Insulated panels essential. Non-insulated sunroom roofs are virtually unusable in summer.
Scenario 4: Mobile home roof-over
You want to improve your mobile home's comfort and appearance.
→ Insulated panels strongly recommended. The comfort and energy savings justify the cost.
Cost vs Value Analysis
The price difference is significant but so is the value:
For a 200 sq ft cover:
- Standard aluminum installed: ~$4,000-5,000
- Insulated panels installed: ~$6,000-9,000
- Difference: ~$2,000-4,000
What that difference buys:
- 10-15° cooler space
- Quiet during storms
- Ceiling fan capability
- 40+ year lifespan
- Finished ceiling look
- Walk-on maintenance access
Over 40 years, that's $50-100 per year for dramatically better performance.
Questions to Ask Yourself
- Will I spend time under this cover?
Yes → Insulated | No → Standard is fine
- Do I want ceiling fans?
Yes → Insulated required | No → Either works
- Will this be enclosed/climate-controlled?
Yes → Insulated essential | No → Consider either
- Is this purely utilitarian?
Yes → Standard is fine | No → Consider insulated
- Is budget severely limited?
Yes → Standard now, upgrade later | No → Insulated for long-term value
The Hybrid Approach
Some homeowners do both:
- Insulated panels over the patio (living space)
- Standard aluminum for the carport (utility space)
This puts the investment where it matters most.
Making Your Decision
For most homeowners building a space for outdoor living, insulated panels are the right choice. The comfort difference is dramatic, the functionality is superior, and the long-term value is clear.
Standard aluminum makes sense for pure utility applications where comfort doesn't matter. There's no shame in the budget option when it meets your actual needs.
Pro Specialty Services installs both systems throughout Lake County. We can help you evaluate your specific situation and make the right choice for your project and budget.
Caleb Hutchinson
Owner, Pro Specialty Services
"The decision usually comes down to one question: Are you going to spend time in this space? If yes, get insulated panels. If the space is just for covering a car or some equipment, standard aluminum is fine. It's really that simple."
